I had some troubles with my first ring, in that the rose gold faded a bit within weeks as I work with my hands a lot, and so they offered to replace it and I chose to change to silver as the other band I had purchased is silver and is holding up much better.
I recommend the silver for any of you who are crafts people or do a lot with your hands.
this is a 4/5 because I am concerned with two things: 1. the amount of packaging was intense! Two boxes filler, and a cloth pouch holding a ring in a plastic pouch, just felt like a lot of extra landfill, and stickers, and a card....I will hope they reconsider the volume of extra. Perhaps do away with the foil and paper filler, and just use a temporary glue on the little box. Perhaps there should be an option for earth conscious shipping where only the minimum shipping materials are used. 2. The volume of emails with no sign on how to unsubscribe.